I think it would be best if I said this right away, this is my own personal opinion, I am not telling anyone what to think, and before Twilight crazed fans decide to ban together with pitch forks and torches, do me a favor and hear me out.
Twilight is really a simple story about a vampire and a girl who are in love. That is it; and there is no more substance than that. Do not get me wrong; there is action and the book does have its fair share of vampire fights, but there is no elaborate plot throughout the series.
What I am saying is, Twilight does not deserve the reputation it has. It has been spoken so highly of; yet the books are underdevoloped.
While reading the series, I excitedly anticipated a shocking plot twist; yet there was none. It did have its twists and turns, but nothing spectacular.
I feel it is unfair when something like Twilight is compared to Harry Potter; that is truly a wonderful series. Harry Potter is really unbelievable. You can see J.K. Rowling really *and I mean really* thought everything out. The story is astonishing; she is a geniu
s.
I do respect and give credit to Stephenie Meyer, and I do not mean to take anything away from her. If you want a simple story, then read Twilight. If you want a story with a considerable amount more substance and thought, do read Harry Potter if you have not already.
I wondered why Twilight was given so much credit. I thought it over, and realized of course girls would love Twilight because Edward, one of our main characters, is, "the perfect guy."
Personally, I think that is a really preposterous reason to give a book so much credit. Edward maybe handsome and respectful and whatnot, but he is obsessive and controlling over the main character and his girlfriend, Bella. For example, many times when Bella wanted to visit her friend Jacob, Edward did not permit her to leave. Bella had to leave in secret.
Oh, Bella. She is another reason why Twilight really is not as good as you think.
Bella's irrational thinking often frustrated me, and I often thought to myself, "If Edward really did know what Bella was thinking, he would never date her."
Edward, being controlling, was already irritating, but Bella giving in to him every time may have been even more so.
Also, it angered me when I first started reason to see Meyer change the nature of the vampire. The vampires in this book are no traditional vampires; no, these ones each have their own little super power, and avoid the sun only because they sparkle in it. *Read the book or watch the movie if you have not and you will understand what I am saying* Let's say, I wrote a book. And in my book I had a dragon. But, the dragon says, "You see, it's a common misconception that we breathe fire and fly. We actually radiate marshmallows and swim!" Does that make him a dragon? Absolutely not! If one is going to twist and change the nature of the vampire, then it is not a vampire anymore.
There are my reasons for disliking the series. They do not deserve the credit they have received. If you want a simple story and something not very developed, then Twilight is a decent read. I give it a 7/10.
Twilight is really a simple story about a vampire and a girl who are in love. That is it; and there is no more substance than that. Do not get me wrong; there is action and the book does have its fair share of vampire fights, but there is no elaborate plot throughout the series.
What I am saying is, Twilight does not deserve the reputation it has. It has been spoken so highly of; yet the books are underdevoloped.
While reading the series, I excitedly anticipated a shocking plot twist; yet there was none. It did have its twists and turns, but nothing spectacular.
I feel it is unfair when something like Twilight is compared to Harry Potter; that is truly a wonderful series. Harry Potter is really unbelievable. You can see J.K. Rowling really *and I mean really* thought everything out. The story is astonishing; she is a geniu
I do respect and give credit to Stephenie Meyer, and I do not mean to take anything away from her. If you want a simple story, then read Twilight. If you want a story with a considerable amount more substance and thought, do read Harry Potter if you have not already.
I wondered why Twilight was given so much credit. I thought it over, and realized of course girls would love Twilight because Edward, one of our main characters, is, "the perfect guy."
Personally, I think that is a really preposterous reason to give a book so much credit. Edward maybe handsome and respectful and whatnot, but he is obsessive and controlling over the main character and his girlfriend, Bella. For example, many times when Bella wanted to visit her friend Jacob, Edward did not permit her to leave. Bella had to leave in secret.
Oh, Bella. She is another reason why Twilight really is not as good as you think.
Bella's irrational thinking often frustrated me, and I often thought to myself, "If Edward really did know what Bella was thinking, he would never date her."
Edward, being controlling, was already irritating, but Bella giving in to him every time may have been even more so.
Also, it angered me when I first started reason to see Meyer change the nature of the vampire. The vampires in this book are no traditional vampires; no, these ones each have their own little super power, and avoid the sun only because they sparkle in it. *Read the book or watch the movie if you have not and you will understand what I am saying* Let's say, I wrote a book. And in my book I had a dragon. But, the dragon says, "You see, it's a common misconception that we breathe fire and fly. We actually radiate marshmallows and swim!" Does that make him a dragon? Absolutely not! If one is going to twist and change the nature of the vampire, then it is not a vampire anymore.
There are my reasons for disliking the series. They do not deserve the credit they have received. If you want a simple story and something not very developed, then Twilight is a decent read. I give it a 7/10.
